Monday, October 4, 2010

What Makes Pop Music?

Let's talk about pop. For purposes of this blog, I'm defining pop pretty much as broadly as I can - including everything from the Zombies and Katy Perry to Mastodon, Pissed Jeans, and CAN. (I probably won't write anything about Katy Perry, unless I have something interesting to say, which is unlikely.)

So, if you define pop in such a way that lyrical content, tonality (eg. heavy vs. pleasant), and chord structure are inconsequential, how do you define it? Well, by my consideration, the single defining feature of pop music is repetition. The earliest pop music is folk music - from Europe, from Africa, wherever - and is differentiated from classical/academic music in the way it's structured. Classical music is something you can consider akin to a straight line. It's designed to end in a different place than it begins, by virtue of the ground it's traveled. There are functions in classical music like recapitulation, which carry their weight based on the power of repetition, but classical music is not defined by its reiteration of the same set of chords.*

Pop, on the other hand, is defined by a structural simplicity. This isn't to say that pop is simple, though - only primal, like musical archetypes. If a classical piece is a straight line, a pop song is a loop. Let's take an example everybody knows: "I Want To Hold Your Hand" by the Beatles. There's a brief verse, followed by a chorus. The verse and chorus repeat, followed by a bridge. Finally, one final verse and chorus bring the song to the end. Written out in a list:

Intro
Verse
Chorus
Verse
Chorus
Bridge
Verse
Chorus
Outro

You're looking at a slight variation of the ur-pop song. Subtract the third verse, or replace it with a solo section, and you have the most popular song structure in pop history. No kidding. Next time you're listening to a song that doesn't seem particularly substantial, try and listen to it in the context of verse/chorus/verse/chorus/bridge/chorus. This is not really a revelation - Nirvana wrote a song called "Verse Chorus Verse" - but it does underscore how much of successful pop music is based on setting expectations.

There's more than one kind of repetition in a song. Chord progressions in pop songs are some easily-digested sequence of chords designed to sound good if you play them sequentially and repeatedly. I won't get into examples right now, because I'd like to take the time to explain why some of them work so well, but you know they're there, and that's the important thing.

At a level further down than chord progressions, you'll find hooks. Hooks are pleasant-sounding melodies used repeatedly during a song. The most common place you'll hear a hook is in the intro to the song, followed by within the chorus. I think that's neat - like how a practiced essay writer will usually clearly communicate the thesis in the introductory paragraph, pop musicians build their songs so the hook (which, ideally, should be the most easily-recalled moment of the song) is set up front and center.

So, to sum up, you've got song structures based on repeated sections, which themselves are built on repeated chord progressions, which feature highlighted, repeated melodies. Concentric circles, you might say. Why, then, do people listen to pop music? By this description, it sounds about as exciting as an eye chart. Well, the secret to good pop music (as I see it) is in how it plays with your expectations.** Again, I understand that that directive is so vague as to be meaningless, but the ways in which pop can work with listeners' expectations are limitless. The departures from expectations are what give it character. Sometimes it's lyrically - the old trope of happy songs with sad lyrics comes to mind. Sometimes expectations met at the highest level are impressive in their own right. Sometimes making a single droning chord into a verse progression is enough to make things interesting. I love listening to music in the context of how it approaches repetition - hopefully I won't call it out too often. Gotta play with your expectations, right?

* Jazz music is an interesting sort of hybrid - based around repetitions of a main theme, called the "head", but typically too elaborate to be as easily comprehensible as pop music. I will probably never write about jazz, because I know next to nothing about it.

** Originally I had written that good pop music subverts expectations, but that imputes too much importance to messing with the listener, which, as beleaguered King Crimson fans will tell you, eventually spills over into indulgence. A proper pop hook is nothing to be ashamed of - if it's catchy, you can't rightly say it's something you'd never expect, but neither does it simply function as you'd expect it to. I look forward to writing about some of the worst pop songs I have ever heard.

No comments:

Post a Comment